Oh Mary!
Broadway

From a Tiny Downtown Stage to the Lyceum: The Oh, Mary! Story

Few Broadway phenomena in recent memory have followed the trajectory of Oh, Mary! The show began as a sub-90-minute downtown play written by and starring Cole Escola, premiered Off-Broadway at the Lucille Lortel Theatre in early 2024 to ecstatic reviews, sold out its entire run, transferred to the Lyceum Theatre on Broadway, and proceeded to dominate the 2024 and 2025 awards seasons. Cole Escola took home a Tony for Best Leading Actor in a Play -- the first non-binary performer to win in that category -- and director Sam Pinkleton won Best Direction of a Play. The show has been in continuous performance at the Lyceum ever since.

What is it actually about? The premise, as the official synopsis puts it, examines "the forgotten life and dreams of Mrs. Lincoln, through the lens of an idiot" -- the idiot being Escola, who wrote the play to give Mary Todd Lincoln a comedic life that history mostly ignored. The Lincoln we usually know is the assassinated president; in Oh, Mary! he is barely a footnote. Marys cabaret aspirations, her drinking, her wickedly drawn tutor, her chaotic court of side characters, and her white-hot rage at being denied the spotlight: that is the play. It is profane, fast-moving, and -- at 80 minutes with no intermission -- absolutely relentless.

The casting rotation is the part Broadway audiences are reacting to most this year. Escola handed off the role of Mary Todd Lincoln to a series of guest stars, each playing the part for a limited window. The rotation has been a brilliant move commercially -- every cast change creates a new launch moment and a new wave of fans coming back to see how each performer takes on the role -- and it has been a true showcase for how different comedic styles can find totally different things in the same script. Maya Rudolph -- the SNL alum, Bridesmaids co-star, and the voice of more iconic comedic moments than fits in one paragraph -- took the role on April 28, 2026 and is playing it through July 5. Her Mary is high-pitched, manic, and physically inventive in a way that brings out the slapstick scaffolding that has always been under the play.

Stepping in on July 6, 2026 for a 10-week run through September 12 is Meg Stalter, the Hacks breakout whose deadpan-into-meltdown style is one of the most distinctive comedy voices working right now. Stalters Broadway debut has been an event in itself -- announced just days before the May 13 reveal and immediately sending ticket searches into the stratosphere. Her Mary is reportedly being tailored to her style, leaning more into the long-silence comedic beats and breakdowns she has built her career on. Further casting after September is being announced as the run continues.

The supporting cast and creative team have stayed largely consistent through the run, anchored by Tony-winner Sam Pinkletons direction. The shows physical comedy is hand-crafted; the timing is studied; the production design -- by dots -- packs a wild visual style into the Lyceum proscenium. Costume designer Holly Piersons work, particularly the elaborate costume changes Mary undergoes throughout, has become a talking point of its own.

The Lyceum Theatre itself is part of the experience. Built in 1903 and designed by Herts and Tallant, it is one of the oldest continuously operating theaters on Broadway and a landmark in its own right -- 922 seats spread across an orchestra, mezzanine, and balcony, with intimate sightlines that put even the cheaper seats remarkably close to the action. Located at 149 West 45th Street between Broadway and Sixth Avenue, it is a five-minute walk from Times Square and steps from most of the midtown subway lines.

BigStub has helped Broadway fans land seats for two-plus decades, and every order ships with a 100 percent buyer guarantee, no hidden fees, and the highest Trustpilot rating in the industry. Pick a date that fits, pick a star you want to see, and lock in the night out.

How to Buy Oh, Mary! Broadway Tickets

Where can I buy Oh, Mary! tickets?

Tickets are available through the official Oh, Mary! website, the Lyceum Theatre box office, Telecharge, Broadway.com, and TodayTix. Verified resale tickets -- often the easiest way to get into sold-out performances or to lock in a specific date -- are available right above on BigStub, with no hidden fees and a buyer guarantee on every order.

What is the performance schedule?

Oh, Mary! runs eight performances a week at the Lyceum Theatre: Tuesday through Friday evening shows, two performances on Saturday, and a matinee on Sunday. Specific call times shift week to week -- check the listings above for the exact showtime on the date you are eyeing.

Who is currently starring as Mary Todd Lincoln?

Maya Rudolph is starring through July 5, 2026. Meg Stalter takes over July 6 through September 12. Further casting after September will be announced as the run continues. The listings above show the showtime by date, and most ticket platforms list the currently-scheduled performer per night.

What should I know about the Lyceum Theatre?

The Lyceum is at 149 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036, between Broadway and Sixth Avenue. It is a 922-seat Shubert-operated venue with an orchestra, mezzanine, and balcony. The closest subway stations are Times Square - 42nd Street (1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, R, W, S) and 49th Street (N, R, W). It is a five-to-ten minute walk from most of midtown.

Is there a dress code?

There is no formal dress code at the Lyceum. Broadway crowds tend to land somewhere between business-casual and "smart casual." That said -- the audience for Oh, Mary! is one of the most stylish on Broadway, so do not be surprised to see some inventive outfits.

What is the age requirement?

Oh, Mary! is recommended for ages 14 and up. Children under the age of 4 are not permitted in the theater, and the content -- profane language, dark comedic themes -- is not appropriate for younger kids. Everyone, regardless of age, requires a ticket.

Are resale tickets on BigStub safe?

Yes. BigStub has been in the resale business for more than 20 years and holds the highest Trustpilot rating in the industry. Every listing comes from a verified seller, every order is backed by a buyer guarantee, and customer service is available before and after the show if anything comes up with the order.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Oh, Mary! about?

Oh, Mary! is Cole Escolas Tony-winning dark comedy that reimagines the life of Mary Todd Lincoln through the lens of an idiot -- the playwright himself. The 80-minute play follows Mary as she pursues her cabaret-singer ambitions, drinks her way through Washington, terrorizes her tutor, and elbows her assassinated husband to the margins of his own story.

Who stars in Oh, Mary! in 2026?

Maya Rudolph plays Mary Todd Lincoln through July 5, 2026. Meg Stalter takes over the role from July 6 through September 12, 2026 for a 10-week limited engagement. Further casting for performances after September is being announced as the run continues. Original star and playwright Cole Escola occasionally returns for special engagements.

When is Maya Rudolph in Oh, Mary!?

Maya Rudolph took the role on April 28, 2026 and plays it through her final performance on July 5, 2026. Her run has been one of the most in-demand engagements of the Broadway season -- if you want to catch her Mary, the listings above show the remaining performances during her window.

When is Meg Stalter in Oh, Mary!?

Meg Stalter takes over the role on July 6, 2026 and plays through September 12, 2026 for a 10-week limited engagement. Her Broadway debut was announced on May 13, 2026 and immediately set off a wave of ticket demand for the summer performances.

Where is Oh, Mary! playing?

Oh, Mary! is playing at the Lyceum Theatre at 149 West 45th Street, between Broadway and Sixth Avenue in midtown Manhattan. It is a five-minute walk from Times Square and steps from most midtown subway lines.

How long is the show?

Oh, Mary! runs approximately 80 minutes with no intermission. The pace is fast and the comedy is dense -- it is one of the shorter Broadway runtimes and one of the most packed shows on Broadway minute-for-minute.

How much do Oh, Mary! tickets cost?

Ticket prices vary by date, performance, and seat location. Tickets typically start at 77 dollars for the lower-priced sections, with premium orchestra seats running significantly higher -- especially during the Maya Rudolph and Meg Stalter runs. The listings above show current pricing for each performance. There is also a daily in-person rush at the Lyceum box office for 43 dollars while supplies last.

Is there a lottery for Oh, Mary!?

Production-side lotteries and rush programs have come and gone during the run -- check the official Oh, Mary! website for the current digital lottery setup. The Lyceum box office also offers in-person rush tickets for 43 dollars on the day of each performance, while supplies last.

What is the age requirement for Oh, Mary!?

Oh, Mary! is recommended for ages 14 and up due to language and dark comedic content. Children under the age of 4 are not permitted in the theater at any time. Every patron, including children, must have their own ticket.

Is Oh, Mary! appropriate for tourists?

Yes -- the show has become a popular tourist destination on Broadway, especially for fans of Cole Escola, Maya Rudolph, Meg Stalter, or modern dark comedy. The 80-minute runtime and the midtown location make it easy to slot into a New York trip. Just be aware the humor is profane and irreverent.

How do I get to the Lyceum Theatre?

The Lyceum Theatre is at 149 West 45th Street between Broadway and Sixth Avenue. The closest subway stations are Times Square - 42nd Street (1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, R, W, S) and 49th Street (N, R, W). Most major bus lines stop within a few blocks, and rideshare drop-off is straightforward on 45th Street or 46th Street.

Is Oh, Mary! ADA accessible?

Yes -- the Lyceum Theatre offers wheelchair-accessible seating, assistive listening devices, and accessible restrooms. Telecharge handles accessible seating requests; contact them directly when booking, or contact Shubert Audience Services for specific accommodations.

What is the buyer guarantee on BigStub?

BigStubs buyer guarantee covers every order: tickets that are not delivered on time, are not valid, or for events that are cancelled outright are replaced or refunded per the marketplace terms. The guarantee is included with every purchase at no extra cost, and customer service is available throughout the process.

Why do tickets cost more on some nights?

Broadway pricing is dynamic, so demand drives the price. Weekend evenings, dates featuring guest stars like Maya Rudolph or Meg Stalter, and holiday weeks all tend to price higher. Weeknight performances during off-peak weeks often offer the best deals. The listings above let you compare prices across the schedule.